核医学と放射線治療

Clinical Significance of Pulmonary Nodules Missed on Non-Breath-Hold PET/CT

Abstract

Seng Thipphavong, Remy C. Lim, Emily C Zabor and Heiko Schöder

Objective: In clinical practice, PET images are acquired during shallow breathing and CT images of the PET/ CT during shallow breathing or at near end-expiration. We determined the clinical significance of pulmonary nodules that were missed on PET/CT acquired during non-breath-hold (NBH) imaging in patients with proven non-thoracic solid malignancies. Methods: 200 consecutive cancer patients who underwent both PET/CT and diagnostic breath-hold (BH) chest CT within 30 days, and who had a follow-up with BH CT at least 2 years after these baseline studies, were evaluated. NBH CT of the PET/CT was analyzed first, followed by the baseline BH CT. Missed nodules were defined as nodules not detected on NBH PET/CT, but detected on BH CT. Missed nodules were then evaluated on BH CT performed at least 2 years later. A second radiologist was used to evaluate inter observer variability for a subset of 50 patients. Results: 343 nodules were identified in 121 patients. 166 nodules from 86 patients were classified as missed nodules. Seven of these 166 nodules were excluded due to interval surgery or development of consolidation. When a change in size was counted only if it was ≥2 mm, only 11 of the 159 nodules (6.9%) grew, 113 nodules (71.1%) did not change, and the remaining 35 nodules (22.0%) were not present at follow-up. Malignancy was deemed the most likely diagnosis in only 6 of the original 159 missed nodules. Conclusion: Although the incidence of pulmonary nodules missed on NBH PET/CT was high, most of these nodules did not show any growth on follow-up and few were proven to be metastatic. Current clinical practice of PET/CT, with acquisition during shallow breathing or at near end expiration is sufficient; performing additional deep inspiration BH CT does not appear warranted.